Council will now discuss its own planning applications in public after Hove Library controversy

Conservative and Green councillors with campaigners outside Hove Library
Conservative and Green councillors with campaigners outside Hove Library

All planning applications involving council-owned buildings will be decided by councillors in future after a long-running row over controversial changes to Hove Library.

Brighton and Hove City Council’s planning committee will discuss any planning applications for the council’s own properties in public.

Hove Library

Hove Library

The change in policy was prompted by the handling of plans to change elements of the historic Carnegie Library in Church Road, Hove, with the basement being converted into a nursery.

Residents and councillors alike were angered by the way in which the planning process was handled.

Criticism centred on the timing of the applications and its associated consultation period – over Christmas and the new year – and a perceived lack of communication with councillors, neighbours and other interested people such as library hours.

The application was open for public comments from Friday, December 8 to Friday, December 29, but was not subsequently discussed by the planning committee.

During the consultation period only four letters of objection were received, with five objections required to trigger a decision by the planning committee rather than officials.

The council’s tourism, development and culture committee was told last night (Thursday, June 21) that a further nine letters arrived after the deadline.

Angry residents have since submitted a 222-signature petition complaining about the timing and decision.

Some of the historic radial shelving is being removed although Conservative councillor Robert Nemeth said that some other more positive changes were now also being made as a result of the fuss.

Former planning committee chair, Green councillor Phélim Mac Cafferty, welcomed the change in policy, describing it as essential in the short term, if not possible to maintain on a long-term basis.

Councillor Mac Cafferty said: “We have to rebuild community trust. This ended up in community mistrust of the entire process and has evolved into mistrust where it’s not needed.”

Labour councillor Adrian Morris said: “It’s a great pity that not enough people came forward with objections.

“The problem of the library shelving and removal of books really needed addressing.

”It’s a lesson for the community – to get much more involved.”

Sarah Booker-Lewis is the Local Democracy Reporter for Brighton & Hove.

For more of her stories, click here.

Related stories:

Hove Library nursery plan set to be approved

Council accused of Hove Library ‘vandalism’

Council presses ahead with new plans for Hove Library